Recently I came across an investment scheme that offered a steady return of Rs 8000 per month based on an initial deposit of Rs 2.5 lakhs which works out to 38.4 per cent per annum. The scheme looks quite impressive. But what kept me pondering is that, in 2007 when the stock market was in the peak of its rally, the returns posted by S&P CNX Nifty & BSE sensex were 54.77 and 47.15 per cent respectively. With the current stock market returns being negative and the risk free return hovering around 10 per cent, a return of 38 per cent seems idealistic.
In the past we have seen the collapse of various chit funds and other investment solutions offering exceptionally high returns. The recent Rs 500 crores swindle by Sabarinath, Managing Director Total 4 U group of companies is a very good example of such schemes. He collected vast sum of deposits from innocent investors by promising an extraordinary return of 60% in an extremely short period of three months. He gained the confidence of potential investors by promptly paying Rs 160,000 to every person who had deposited Rs 100,000. But then, he got to a stage when he could not keep his promise any longer.
Again, Last week there was the news of former Nasdaq chairman Bernard Madoff and founder of brokerage firm Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities LLC in a similar situation. 1Bernard’s firm has been offering investors a steady yearly return of 10-12 per cent for about two decade, no matter how the markets performed. His company recycled capital of new investors to repay the older ones until the scheme went flat.
This does not mean that all investment firm offering high returns are to be viewed suspiciously. There are several hedge funds and private fund managers who have given significantly high return consistently over a period of time. A good example is George Soros’s Quantum Funds which has given an average annual return of 41% in the past 5 years.
It therefore becomes important to consider the global economic situation, the prevailing interest rate in the economy and the deployment of the funds to get a general idea about the expected returns. One must study the economies, markets, companies & assets were the funds are going to be deployed along with a good background check of the promoters & management of the firm offering investment solutions.
1 Column : Bernard Madoff Ponzi, The financial express, Sanjay Banerji, 2008-12-17.